Toronto: 'Butter' spreads a publicity stunt on the media, but the movie is a smear of condescending political attitudes


Image Credit: Steve Dietl

The publicity stunt recently whipped up for Butter at the Toronto Film Festival worked like a charm: By extending an “invitation” to Minnesota Congresswoman and Republican Presidential candidate Michele Bachmann to “co-host” an Iowa premiere of the political satire, Harvey Weinstein and company cleverly grabbed media headlines, employing impish Michael Moore-style tactics to stake out a political position that’s presumably catnip to the movie’s left-learning and/or Democratic base.

Mission accomplished! But that still leaves Butter to cut through, and for my vote, the movie has the backfiring effect of making its liberal core audience look just as smug, self-righteous, and condescending as conservative opposition insists it is. The dairy product in the title refers to a butter-carving competition that climaxes in a showdown between a pageant-pretty, small-minded, scheming, conservative heartland wife with the vinegar-y name of Laura Pickler (Jennifer Garner) and a talented, open-minded African-American foster child with the sweet, Beyoncé-like name of Destiny (Yara Shahidi). Any allusions to Sarah Palin and Barack Obama are strictly intentional, especially since Garner plays around with a Palinesque voice and accent. Of course, the movie wouldn’t exist without Best In Show, American Beauty, and Election to demonstrate how this kind of thing is done — much better. There’s more than a touch of Election‘s Tracy Flick in Mrs. Pickler’s tightly wound, perky/steely determination to get ahead, and not enough lessons learned from Best In Show on how to achieve a buoyant balance between mockery and affection.

Butter melts, I think, because British director Jim Field Smith and newcomer screenwriter Jason Micallef can’t or don’t care to distinguish the elements of audacity and satirical cleverness from those of mockery and crudeness. And when in doubt, they fall back on cheap “outrageousness” in speech and deed to prod the audience. I don’t think I’ve ever heard as much vulgar discussion of genitals as I have at the movies in this year’s festival. Butter adds to the conversation with the comments of a former beau of Laura’s (he owns a car dealership, so obviously he’s full of bull), a dim dupe she seduces in order to enlist him in as her accomplice in rigging the carving competition. Played pleased-as-punch by Hugh Jackman in a cowboy hat, this dumb ol’ boy gratuitously comments on the state of his old girlfriend’s current vagina. God bless America!

Butter fancies itself a movie that gets in your face, only to conclude, in Weinstein Company house-style, with an oily dollop of sentimentality. Representative Bachmann might do well to screen the thing for her followers as an example of everything she’s fighting against. She’d gain more support than that publicity stunt could have imagined.

Read more:
Toronto: Jennifer Garner ‘a little over’ playing nice, gets nasty in ‘Butter’
Toronto: Harvey Weinstein challenges Michele Bachmann at ‘Butter’ premiere
Director Jim Field Smith talks about his upcoming comedy ‘Butter’

Comments (24 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2
  • LM

    Well said, Lisa.

    • gary

      I am a mature and air force man. i just think here is a good place to meet friends. i just wonder if i can meet a sweet girl there, because i wanna have a long relationship..i uploaded my hot photos on —-[millionaireluv__c’o’m ]—-under the name manuel2011 , maybe you want to check out my photos firstly!

    • Daniel

      Any suggestions on comnig back from hamstring injury. I seem to be healthy physically but I also seem to have broken my brain. There seems to be a loss of intensity. I am the ultimate running scared right now. After two runs I was convinced that I was going to blow up my hamstring. Tried to just focus op pose running. When I got back home I checked my times and they were about 10-20 sec faster per 600m than two months ago. And I know I can run cause my box had an 800m run as part of a WOD on Tuesday and I was faster than the others without any pain. Frustrated!!! Any thoughts out there?

  • Brigid

    Obviously I haven’t seen it, but the last article I read compared Garner’s character to Hillary Clinton, not Palin.

    • Marc

      I saw the movie for myself at TIFF on Wednesday, and the Jennifer Garner character, despite her conservative views, is definitely modelled after Hillary Clinton, not Palin. Very funny movie if I do say so, even if the political satire only works sporadically.

  • Lighten up… it’s only a movie. Is Lisa now a Tea Party member?

    Getting offended over a Michael Moore movie makes sense to me (he can be an instigator, though he is also is a good filmmaker if he wants to). But getting offended over a movie like this is just plain silly. Lisa, if they want to target liberal audiences, then just let them. It’s not a campaign tool, it’s a marketing one. Just like comic book films have a right to target fantasy fans, movies like this have a right to target their demographic.

    • John Moser

      Lisa never suggested that they don’t “have a right to target their demographic”, you know, smug, self-righteous, and condescending liberals. It’s also telling that you deny that it’s a campaign tool, when Lisa also never said that.

  • Cat

    I saw a pre screening of this a few months ago and I think you hit the nail on the head. Very condescending film.

  • Steven

    I actually got to read the screenplay two years ago (they probably have changed most of it by then) and I thought it read very entertainingly. Some parts didn’t pace well in my mind but it still was fun to get through. One point of advice… when watching the movie, imagine Olivia Wilde’s character is actually Megan Fox and you will realize it is the PERFECT role for her.

  • Christa

    Wow, that’s Jennifer Garner? I totally thought that was a man in drag. Whoops!

  • Adwina Lambert

    jen g does look like a man indrag tee-hee!

  • viviennewestwood

    This is some great news. With a few new sites going live this is excellent information to use to make a plan of action. I just had to drop which you line to mention that i thoroughly enjoyed this post from yours, I get subscribed for a RSS feeds and have skimmed a few of your articles or blog posts before but this one really were standing out in my situation. Youll appreciate your appreciation. Together with keep operating a blog. Thanks again guys for sharing such excellent information!

  • coachfactoryoutlet

    Interesting post and view, hope to hear more what the future holds THANKS Great post. Probably saved thousands of hours between everybody here. For me,this clearly is a heads up on which methods to focus on to maximise my online success . Ill start concentrating on your other articles instead. Really great advice. Thanks for sharing.

  • coachfactoryoutlet

    Thank you for providing us with such information. Really interesting stuff guys. You made some good points there, I will definitely take care of that. I did a search on the topic and found most people will agree with your blog. Anyway, this is terrific information to know. Good job on your research too!

  • viviennewestwood

    Interesting post and view, hope to hear more what the future holds THANKS Great post. Probably saved thousands of hours between everybody here. For me,this clearly is a heads up on which methods to focus on to maximise my online success . Ill start concentrating on your other articles instead. Really great advice. Thanks for sharing.

  • coachfactoryoutlet

    Great article. I cant wait to hear more about your research tool. If it is as good as your other products, then you will have another winner. Your article pretty much summed up what I have been seeing too. Great to see some hard data.

  • coachfactoryoutlet

    Thanks for disclosing this research to us. Wowww , real extense article, i found it brief and targeted to the point. I could tell how great you are in your field of interest. You could relate in each detail very well. Thank you for spending a time on sharing such informative writings to us. I will bookmark your page and looking forward to read some more of your writings soon.

  • viviennewestwood

    Thanks for interesting blog post. You guys are always provide information that it makes it impossible not to want to buy your next product ;I cant wait to see what you guys come up with based on all your research and data that you gather.

  • viviennewestwood

    Youareamazing! This weblog is so great. I really hope a lot more people read this and get what you are saying, cause let me tell you, its critical stuff. I never would have thought about it this way unless I would run into your web site. Thanks for sharing it. I hope youve excellent achievement.

Page: 1 2
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos in Movies


From Our Partners

TV Recaps

Powered by VIP