Sundance 2011: 'Project Nim,' 'The Ledge,' and a title that's a mouthful

sundanceImage Credit: Clayton Chase/Getty ImagesI love the magical communal moment that occurs at Sundance at the end of every movie just before the theater lights come up. While the credits roll, hundreds and hundreds of moviegoers bow their heads in prayer, murmuring over tiny votive candles, and the auditorium appears to be dotted with sacred points of light piercing the darkness. At first I thought those miniature beacons reflected this year’s Sundance marketing and design theme, “Be There,” articulated in a warm voice-over narration by festival founder Robert Redford in the video tag before every screening. “Imagine a world without stories,” Redford murmurs, as flickering lightbulbs fill the screen. But now that my eyes have had a day to focus, I realize that the miracle I’ve been witnessing is the collective glow of electronic hand-held devices as attendees fall into deep contemplation of urgent confessions sent by fellow souls within the last two hours, intelligence along the lines of, “I’m 4 rows Bhind U! L8R!”

I saw five films on the first full day of Sundance and one on opening night. And while I don’t recommend this pace of cinematic consumption on a steady basis — over time, the lack of fresh air and sunshine-vitamin-D can mess with critical attention — I do always enjoy that initial immersion as a kind of all-in leap into the fray, and an opportunity to noodle around with bigger notions of current filmmaking as filtered through the Sundance experience.  Project Nim, for example, James Marsh’s engrossing documentary about the arduous life of one famous chimpanzee, brings to life Elizabeth Hess’ essential, deeply reported 2008 book, Nim Chimpsky: The Chimp Who Would Be Human. This chimp’s life was an appallingly hard one: Nim was wrested away from his mother as a newborn, raised as a human child and taught sign language in a vague scientific experiment, passed from human keeper to keeper with utter disregard, and abused, for a long, inhumane stretch, as a test animal in a medical lab. Using techniques that reflect the work of Errol Morris and a storytelling voice pitched somewhere between lyrical compassion and acerbic WTF?, Marsh (who used a very different voice to make Man On Wire) creates an implied link between the indignities endured by one magnificent animal and the apesh– behavior of the blithely fallible, romantically tangled, hippie-era humans who took Nim into their homes. You don’t need to be Charles Darwin to appreciate Marsh’s close study of human monkey business.

Sarah-Paulson-MarthaImage Credit: Jody Lee LipesIt’s near impossible to say the name of Sean Durkin’s feature debut, Martha Marcy May Marlene, without first pausing to gather the four names in the right order, and not add Mary, Marla, or Mandy to the arbitrary string of M’s. Even the festival’s quick-witted director, John Cooper, needed a bit of a King’s Speech pause to get the word string right during his introduction. (So here’s a vote for a future title change.) Besides, Mx4 is all the same girl — a depressed, uncommunicative young woman played by Elizabeth Olsen, a beautiful if opaque, effortlessly photogenic newcomer who may or may not be tired of being referred to as the young sister of twins Mary-Kate and Ashley O. When we first meet MMMM, she’s escaping from the unspecific, abusive cult in which she has been living as a harem member for two years, hidden away in the Catskills. The Charles Manson-like cult-leader  (John Hawkes, still burning off some of his Winter’s Bone intensity) has named the very pretty, weirdly passive girl Marcy May. But she returns to her birth name, Martha, when she goes to live with her sister, Lucy (Sarah Paulsen), and her sister’s husband, Ted (Hugh Dancy), at their luxurious Connecticut lake house. I leave the identity of Marlene for the viewer to discover.

Two years of cult life, the amenities of which include rape, can make a woman crazy. Understandably, MMMM arrives at her sister’s lakeside doorstep traumatized and nearly catatonic. The frustration of Mx4 is that, Durkin — like many other young graduates of the Sundance Institute Screenwriters and Directors Lab — is more adept at adding Interesting Story Elements than at making the story unfold with organic inevitability. There’s not one clue as to why Martha Etc. was drawn to a cult in the first place, or who she really is, or why she makes the choices she does, or why Lucy can’t get a clue, right from the get-go, that her estranged sister is in dire psychological shape and needs help.

Also? Also? I am tired, tired, tired of beautiful adult female characters who act and talk like zombies, little girls, and mentally challenged hothouse flowers while the camera caresses their flawless bodies. Grow up! Use your words! Answer questions when asked, keep your shirt on, and don’t bite your lips!

Which brings me to The Ledge, by Matthew Chapman, who notes in his bio that he’s the great-great-grandson of Charles Darwin (Chapman may want to chat with Nim‘s James Marsh), and that his intention is to “marry his love of the thriller with his fascination with religious extremism.” Welllllll…..Chapman does go out on a ledge, I’ll give him that. So does a guy named Gavin (Charlie Hunnam), threatening suicide high above a Baton Rouge street. A cop/suicide negotiator named Hollis (Terrence Howard) is trying to talk Gavin down. See, Gavin is an amiable, sexy, non-religious, hotel middle-manager. And he develops a thing with his married neighbor (Liv Tyler), who comes to work as a housemaid at his hotel, looking like a chaste schoolgirl because she’s the wife of a stern born-again Christian (Patrick Wilson) who thinks that, among other beliefs, homosexuality is an abomination — which is problem because Gavin’s roommate is gay. Meanwhile, Hollis is a Roman Catholic with marital troubles and…Whoa! The characters are placed like strategic pinheads (you heard me) on a map of religious options, not one of which is honestly explored. The born-again Christian is lit with a sinister glow and Wilson plays him with a mad glint. The characters don’t so much discuss different attitudes toward faith and religion as spout paragraphs of text. The movie is crazy with “thriller” gestures that evoked unintentional laughs among the movie-wise Sundance audience.

And as played by Tyler with her whispery voice, grave and moist gazes, and slow physical gestures, the female in this story is a play doll, a shivering doe, a seductive yet passive school girl in need of male protection, and a grown-up who doesn’t know how to speak like grown-ups do. The camera does like her bod, though.

Comments (10 total) Add your comment
  • Steven

    Bitter much Lisa?

  • Tom

    Do you plan on seeing “Page One: A Year Inside the New York Times”?

  • sammy sam

    Bitter? Why would she be? If the movies sucked, that’s her opinion. They most likely did

  • talkin’

    Well said, Lisa.

  • Cate

    Doesn’t sound bitter to me. Sounds like a perfectly reasonable, if slightly exhausted, critique.

  • Justin

    All these films sounded dumb on their premise alone. Weren’t there better options?

  • ekarlinsky

    I so agree with your review of The Ledge. It was so cliche and sophomoric.

  • coachfactoryoutlet

    Great article. I cant wait to hear more about your research tool. If it is as good as your other products, then you will have another winner. Your article pretty much summed up what I have been seeing too. Great to see some hard data.

  • tresorparis

    Youareamazing! This weblog is so great. I really hope a lot more people read this and get what you are saying, cause let me tell you, its critical stuff. I never would have thought about it this way unless I would run into your web site. Thanks for sharing it. I hope youve excellent achievement.

  • ghdsaleuk

    Great article. I cant wait to hear more about your research tool. If it is as good as your other products, then you will have another winner. Your article pretty much summed up what I have been seeing too. Great to see some hard data.

Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos in Movies


From Our Partners

TV Recaps

Powered by VIP